Which car rental company provides the best service? We acted as a potential business car customer and discovered that while some firms were excellent, several left a lot to be desired. Tom Webster reports

10. Apex 32%

Apex scored poorly in all areas other than services offered, and was not helped by the fact that it has no hybrids on the books.

www.apexrental.co.uk

9. 1Car1 36%

No hybrids, carbon-offsetting or city cars – all contribute to a low score in every category for 1Car1.

www.1car1.com

8. Thrifty 44%

In the absence of a specific carbon-offsetting scheme, Thrifty is aiming to cut emissions by positioning dealerships in areas of greatest demand.

www.thrifty.co.uk

=6. Hertz 52%

In the absence of a specific carbon-offsetting scheme, Thrifty is aiming to cut emissions by positioning dealerships in areas of greatest demand.

www.hertz.co.uk

=6. Sixt 52%

With self-management available from the fourth quarter of 2008, Sixt could be much higher up the table this time next year.

www.sixt.co.uk

5. Avis 72%

With five cars offered in the sub-121g/km category everything looked promising. What a shame no-one responded to our online enquiry.

www.avis.co.uk

4. Europcar 76%

Automated email response was the quickest of all, taking just 10 minutes. However, after promising personal contact from a company rep, none came.

www.europcar.co.uk

3. Budget 80%

A good all-round score. Allows driver reports to be tailored to individual needs and has a dedicated small business department called Business Connections.

www.budget.co.uk

2. National 84%

While there is no carbon offsetting being offered at National at the moment, plans are afoot to bring in a scheme.

www.nationalcar.co.uk

1. Enterprise 92%

Email response was good with an auto reply, personal message and follow-up email which was nearly perfect – full marks would have been gained if it had been perfect.

www.enterprise.co.uk

BACK…